IU Panel's Business Outlook: Charming and Wretched

For more of my commentary on life in Richmond, Indiana check out RichmondMatters.com.
(Please note, because of the time that has passed since I wrote this article, it may no longer reflect my current views or the most accurate and complete information available on this subject.)

Last Monday I had the opportunity to attend the Indiana University Kelley School of Business's "Business Outlook Panel" during their luncheon stop in Richmond to provide a forecast of the national, state-wide and local economies for 2006. Sponsored by Bank One (er, Chase Bank) and Richmond Baking and well attended, it was an interesting event all around:

IMG_0124.JPGFor one, it was attended by 17 young adults from the "Young Adult Professionals" group that's been growing here in town (and with which I'm now involved). I took it from the reactions of the other community members at the event - during and after - that this turnout of younger folk was pleasantly surprising and encouraging. Rob Quigg and the Richmond Baking Company largely made that possible, I believe, sponsoring the costs for at least some of those attendees and rounding us up to get butts in chairs. Thanks, Rob!

Less encouraging was the actual business outlook. In fact, it was pretty bleak all around: the panelists were in consensus that they were "apprehensively optimistic" about our economic future in 2006 and beyond. Okay...but for me it was scary to hear the reasons for their optimism...things like "as long as the price per barrel of oil doesn't go above $70 for very long, we'll be okay" and "as long as there's no real collapse in the real estate market" aren't really factors I want to set store by. In the end, despite some sound logic related to ways that things could get better, they were mostly diagnosing an only mildly candy-coated case of necrosis for the area's traditional economic health.

Even worse: by the format and tone of the event, you'd think we'd been told that help is on the way and everything will be just fine. A charming lunch at the Forest Hills Country Club. Laughter as the panelists made light of their adventures in economic forecasting. Warmth and camaraderie as we swallowed the black pill together and got up to go back to our jobs and lives. There wasn't any sense that "we can do anything about this" or even "we *should* do something about this," just another business networking event. Okay, I know *some* people there were furrowing their brow and sharing some pain with those around them, but in general that's just not the professional thing to do.

As I often am, I was again disappointed by the ever-present premise that everything related to the local economy is largely a factor of external variables and forces well beyond our control, and that it has to stay that way. It's a global economy, let's just huddle in our own corners and wait out the storm. Here we had a collection of some of Wayne County's most invested and "powerful" business leaders, decision makers, millionaires and more...and they were all facing forward, not there to discuss or be inventive, just to get more bad news. Of the 1.5 hours spent, only about 10 minutes were devoted to questions from the audience, which did start to bring up some good topics for further discussion, but then it was over. So it wasn't much of a forum in that sense. I would have given up lunch and taken the day off work if they'd had some break-out sessions or follow-up debriefing or...anything where we could roll up our sleeves. But I guess that on some days we only have time and energy to see the iceberg; reacting is put off for another time or place.

Other random factoids and quotes from the panel:

  • "The rest of the country is passing [Indiana] by."
  • The manufacturing sector in Indiana is flat and will never again be a vital part of our economy
  • Indiana is ranked 44th in the nation for state economic growth
  • The average income in the state is 91% of the national average.
  • We're more dependent on manufacturing than any other state.
  • Our best areas of growth in the state for 2006 will be in health and education, leisure activities, and the hospitality industry
  • Locally, the panelists pointed to things like the exciting new strip mall and the activities of the EDC as the bright spots in our growth for 2006. They noted that the Stanley W. Hayes Memorial Strip Mall (a.k.a. Richmond Square Village) will bring an estimated 200 jobs to the area.
  • 63,120 of the 67,780 employable workers are actually working, or about 93.1%
  • Housing is doing reasonably well, sales are up and it's a buyers market, but the local median price of a home is $93,000, compared to the $205,000 median nationally
  • The banking sector is picking up

One thought on “IU Panel's Business Outlook: Charming and Wretched

  1. We can change our future by agreeing to invest in the necessary infrastructure that is required to be competitive but it takes calculated risks and sustained efforts at facing the reality of what it takes to succeed. It also means losing old efforts that no longer work and trying new things. No one else will do this for us. We have to believe enough in ourselves to make the necessary investments. We cannot expect the market to do it for us nor the private sector to have the answers. The private sector is not a great catalyst. This is the purpose of the EDC... to lead us into new venues that are based on accepted and desired principles attrative to private sector companies and become an advocate for change and progress and taking the calculated investment risks to get us to the new outcomes we all desire. Many communities are thriving in these times and they all have that common element of self-driven investments in their vision for the future. It is up to us all to try to get outside of the box on how to achieve these new economic goals.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *